"You" are the problem! Arthur Roche, Prefect of the Dicastery of Divine Worship

I bring to your attention this exclusive interview by Thomas Edwards of ADVATICANUM. 

Exclusive interview: Cardinal Roche to traditionalists: ‘You are edging yourself away from the centre of Catholicism’ | Advaticanum

Exclusive interview: Cardinal Roche to traditionalists: ‘You are edging yourself away from the centre of Catholicism’ | Advaticanum

It is painful to read for two reasons. First, because it reveals the thinking of the Church's current leadership and explains the recent action of Frank Leo of Toronto, the only bishop in Canada to so cruelly and harshly attach the faithful who desire to worship God in the ancient use of the Latin Rite. As this photo shows from June 2026, Frank Leo is doing Arthur Roche's bidding.

Second, it reveals the manipulative and twisted mind of Roche. He makes a ridiculous statement of "amice to amice in 15 minutes" as an excuse. Whatever liturgical abuse was present at the time he served as an altar boy is irrelevant to the issue of the Mass. We can all give examples of liturgical abuse before 1969 or 1965 and most certainly every day today. 

Further, Roche is a liar. He states that "Summorum Pontificum was created to accommodate the FSSPX” This is fundamentally false, as Peter Seewald revealed in 2017 with Emeritus Pope Benedict XVI.

Fundamentally, these churchmen hate you. They believe that you and I are ruining the Church. We are the problem. In Toronto, about 1,500 people a week are responsible for ruining the agenda. Yes, that is what this is about. We are ruining their agenda. Next Sunday, Frank Leo has ordered all parishes to count the attendees at Mass. What will he find? We already know. Except in specific suburban parishes filled with Filipino, Hispanic and Asian and some African immigrants, the church in Toronto is dying. At some point, Frank Leo will need to come to the conclusion that he will need to close 20 parishes in the older part of Toronto itself. All of them have failed. The "NO MASS FOR YOU" period of shuttered churches by Thomas Collins was a disaster for parishes; they have never fully recovered. These men have failed us for nearly 60 years.

These men, Roche and his ilk, know they have failed and their time is short. It is not this writer that is "edging away"; it is Roche and his ilk. They are edging away from not only the centre of the faith but from more. They are edging away from life itself. What they tell you, they are. Roche is a classic gaslighter!

They are cruel and wicked. They have no supernatural faith. They hate the Mass, they hate the Church, they hate Our Lord Jesus Christ, and they hate you, dear reader. How do I know? Because if they do not, then they would not do the things they do.

Let's be clear here. Summorum Pontificum actually created unity. It was an act of love, care, kindness and truth. Traditionis custodes and all that has come from it was and remains a cruel document based on lies and a wicked agenda. The division, the anger, the hurt and the sadness now being experienced by Catholics in Toronto at Holy Family, St. Vincent de Paul, St. Lawrence the Martyr and St. Patrick's Schomberg is not our fault. It is the fault of those who did this. The men appointed to be our shepherds are in fact, fully revealed by the Apostle John in the words of Our Lord.

They are effeminate cretins. Hirelings. All of them!

John 10:1-14 

Amen, amen I say to you: He that entereth not by the door into the sheepfold, but climbeth up another way, the same is a thief and a robber. 2 But he that entereth in by the door is the shepherd of the sheep. 3 To him the porter openeth; and the sheep hear his voice: and he calleth his own sheep by name, and leadeth them out. 4 And when he hath let out his own sheep, he goeth before them: and the sheep follow him, because they know his voice. 5 But a stranger they follow not, but fly from him, because they know not the voice of strangers. 6 This proverb Jesus spoke to them. But they understood not what he spoke to them. 7 Jesus therefore said to them again: Amen, amen I say to you, I am the door of the sheep. 8 All others, as many as have come, are thieves and robbers: and the sheep heard them not. 9 I am the door. By me, if any man enter in, he shall be saved: and he shall go in, and go out, and shall find pastures. 10 The thief cometh not, but for to steal, and to kill, and to destroy. I am come that they may have life and may have it more abundantly. 11 I am the good shepherd. The good shepherd giveth his life for his sheep. 12 But the hireling, and he that is not the shepherd, whose own the sheep are not, seeth the wolf coming, and leaveth the sheep, and flieth: and the wolf catcheth, and scattereth the sheep: 13 And the hireling flieth, because he is a hireling: and he hath no care for the sheep. 14 I am the good shepherd; and I know mine, and mine know me.

Frank Leo spox Neil MacCarthy admits the move is to force you to attend the Novus Ordo

The Catholic Register, owned by the "Metropolitan" Archdiocese of Toronto, has finally written about the harsh enforcement by Cardinal Frank Leo of Traditionis Custodes, a cruel and unjustified document based on falsehoods and manipulation. This motu proprio by Pope Francis suspended Summorum Pontificum and has upset the peace and lives of thousands of Catholics who were finally given the concern and fatherly care under our dear Pope Benedict XVI.

Neil MacCarthy, long-time communications director, announced that the reason is not that there are not enough Masses offered according to the Novus Ordo at the four parishes but rather, "to bring those who do not attend the Novus Ordo to begin to do so."

Traditional Mass exception for Toronto comes with a condition | The Catholic Register 

Do these people think those attending the Usus Antiquior of the Holy Mass are foolish or stupid? We know we can attend the new rite and accept it as valid. Yet we have been called by the Holy Spirit to worship God in this form in the manner of our ancestors. It is not preference or a whim or a fetish. Frank Leo and Neil MacCarthy seem unable to grasp this. Despite Frank Leo’s recent eloquent words on stewardship two weeks ago and yesterday on thanksgiving, he has shown no fatherly care or affection for those attending the traditional Mass. No appreciation for sacred music or church tradition. One only needs to look at the music program at the Cathedral now versus five years ago or a decade ago, or the early 1980s, to see what has happened. All the good work done there for a century has been reduced to the lowest common denominator.

The faithful aren’t foolish, even if we’re like sheep; we know the difference between a true shepherd and a mere hireling. We can tell tenderloin from flank. Some may see this as a simple affectation on our part, but it’s far more than that. It’s a calling from God through the Holy Spirit that has guided these Catholics along this path.

Rather than take the attitude that Catholics attending the traditional liturgy are the problem in the Church today or ruining the Church, look around at the damage left by abuse, which comes in many forms. Look around at the dearth of liturgical awareness in 98% of parishes. Shall we consider the lack of proper formation of the faithful and catechesis, the attendance at Mass, the decline, especially since the acquiescence to the gods of Covid. You ask if I accept Vatican II. Yes, do you? How about that part about "Latin is to be preserved." Or how about, "Gregorian chant has pride of place." 

Perhaps His Eminence and Neil might wish to open their bible to Acts, chapter 5, verses 32 to 39.

32 And we are witnesses of these things and the Holy Ghost, whom God hath given to all that obey him. 33 When they had heard these things, they were cut to the heart, and they thought to put them to death.  34 But one in the council rising up, a Pharisee, named Gamaliel, a doctor of the law, respected by all the people, commanded the men to be put forth a little while. 35 And he said to them: Ye men of Israel, take heed to yourselves what you intend to do, as touching these men. 36 For before these days rose up Theodas, affirming himself to be somebody, to whom a number of men, about four hundred, joined themselves: who was slain; and all that believed him were scattered, and brought to nothing. 37 After this man, rose up Judas of Galilee, in the days of the enrolling, and drew away the people after him: he also perished; and all, even as many as consented to him, were dispersed. 38 And now, therefore, I say to you, refrain from these men, and let them alone; for if this council or this work be of men, it will come to nought; 39 But if it be of God, you cannot overthrow it, lest perhaps you be found even to fight against God. And they consented to him.

Catholic faithful from SSPX barred by Cardinal Frank Leo from venerating relics at Martyrs Shrine

Frank Cardinal Leo, an eminent resident of the Metropolitan Lawrence Park neighbourhood, (Vox Cantoris: The new Bishop's Palace in the Metropolitan Archdiocese of Lawrence Park) recently prevented the Society of St. Pius X from entering St. Joseph's Church in Ignace to honour the relics of the Canadian Martyrs, who were executed by the peace-loving, kind and generous indigenous Iroquois, who failed to understand that every soul matters. 

Look, I get it. An "excommunication." But they have filed an appeal under Canon Law, so the "excommunication" is stayed. Can we not show a little kindness and care to our fellow Catholics? Is this cruelty really necessary?

Yes, cruelty—that’s exactly what Frank Leo's decision to restrict the traditional liturgy in Toronto is, and that’s precisely what this is. Cruel, mean, without charity or fatherly care.

How did the Society respond? How did their leadership advise the people?

In an address to the pilgrims, the superior of the Canadian district, Fr. Yves Le Roux, asked the faithful to accept this decision without bitterness: “Without hesitation, without bitterness touching our souls, we fully submit to this decision of the Cardinal. We assure His Eminence of our prayers for him and publicly reiterate our love for the Holy Church, Mother and Teacher of Truth.”

Let us ask ourselves. Where is the real Christian charity?

The faithful deserve more from their Archbishop. 

Canada: Pilgrimage to the Holy Martyrs Despite the Ban by the Cardinal of Toronto | FSSPX News

St. Michael the Archangel - intercede for the faithful in Toronto!

Letter to Francis Cardinal Leo from a young male Catholic in Toronto.

Letter to Francis Cardinal Leo from a young male Catholic in Toronto. Name and parish withheld upon request. 

His Eminence, Frank Cardinal Leo, Archbishop of Toronto

Office of the Archbishop, Archdiocese of Toronto

Catholic Pastoral Centre

1155 Yonge St.

Toronto, ON M4T 1W2 

Mississauga, ON A1A 1A1 

September 17, 2026

 Dear Eminence, 

Greetings, Your Eminence, from this poor sheep. I come to you with great love and respect, as a child approaching his father to discuss important matters. 

It has recently come to my attention, as a resident of the Archdiocese who is attached to the usus antiquor, that You will be implementing Traditionis Custodes as of September 20^th, 2026. Over nine years, I have happily attended Mass following the usus antiquor at Carmel Heights, Holy Family, St. Vincent de Paul, and St. Lawrence the Martyr. Thus, it was with deep dismay and concern that I received the news, and it is with the same dismay and concern I write this letter. 

Much of this concern and dismay stems from how cruel this action is, and how it contradicts Your presentation as a kind, compassionate, and receptive shepherd. Upon Your installation in March 2023, I reflected with happiness on Your devotion to the Blessed Virgin. You seemed to embody those traits common to Her and Our Lord Jesus Christ: generosity, magnanimity, and an encompassing concern for Your flock. Such qualities are embodied particularly well in your pastoral messages. One example I regularly ponder is found in Your Message for the World Day for Grandparents and the Elderly. There, you write, “Can money, comfortable lifestyle, convenience, material wealth, power, expedient use of resources truly constitutes the “be all and end all” of human existence, the summum bonum for which we must strive? […] Redemptive suffering is regrettably not being preached or taught as it should.” You go on to highlight how requesting MAiD in this mindset is a “sin against God’s love.” Reading this, I was pleased to consider You my bishop. As commissioned by Our Lord Jesus, You were making disciples of all nations and spreading the Gospel. Your words were at once generous, challenged me to offer the pains of life with great love, and displayed an awareness of what we in the pews face on a regular basis. It was gratifying to see, and I noted with pleasure Your demonstrated commitment to visit those smaller, less well-regarded parishes in the Archdiocese. Simply, Your Eminence, Your actions gave further weight to Your words. 

Compounding my happiness at Your commitment to the Gospel was how it has trickled down to my local parish. Before Your installation, Your Eminence, (NAME WITHELD) parish in Mississauga was rather reserved in its practice of the Faith. Today, the Holy Ghost is easily discerned there. An Adoration chapel has been installed which sees regular use. The sanctuary has been enriched with a sobering crucifix, flanked by wonderful statues of St. Joseph and Mary. In the rotunda, proper alcoves have been furnished for Our Lady of Mount Carmel and our patronal saint. Last week, our nave doors were replaced and now depict several Carmelite saints. Every Sunday, the priests offer Mass without fuss, and remind us in their sermons of sin, mercy, justice, the importance of living out of the Gospel, and much more. As a consequence, mindful of their – and Your Eminence’s – practice of generosity, I have begun putting money in the collection plate. As you have noted, money is not the “be all and end all” of my life. The parish is livelier, with more community events than in decades prior. It gives me hope for the future. 

Given such evidence, Your Eminence, I am confused by Your decision to implement Traditionis Custodes to the letter. It goes against everything I have noticed in You. It was enacted without warning. No announcement has been made on the Archdiocesan website. I am unaware of any lay consultation. I had to find out through friends, to my great distress. Where was the kindness? Where was the compassion? Where was the awareness of the trials of life? Since Traditionis Custodes was introduced in 2021, I have witnessed a gradual witling down of the usus antiquor’s offerings here in the Archdiocese. The effects of this have been incalculable. To give just one example, people have been going to other dioceses to hear the Mass of the Ages on Sundays. This is not how it should be. As residents of the Archdiocese of Toronto, we should be able to remain close to home to hear Mass. Pushing us to travel long distances on a Sunday to hear the Mass of my grandparents, at the expense of building the domestic church, is an aberration. It defies history, sense, and charity. To his credit, Your predecessor, His Eminence Emeritus Thomas Cardinal Collins, recognized this, and allowed yours truly to attend the usus antiquor any Sunday I wish. Contrariwise, Your decision to severely restrict the offering of the usus antiquor to certain Sundays, instead of every Sunday, is regrettable.

My confusion is multiplied by the fact Your Eminence has not deemed it necessary to ensure the novus ordo Missae is offered well, with decorum, reverence, and precision. While St. PARISH WITHELD offers acceptable Masses, it could be better. Music is often lacking finesse; I have heard guitars on more than one occasion. When laypeople handle the sacred vessels before and after Mass, they do not wear gloves. Against the late Pope Benedict XVI’s injunction, applause is heard during Mass. These and other actions cause me distress. I have left Mass with tears in my eyes at how Our Lord is treated with such ingratitude and disrespect, heaping, of course, the heaviest charge on myself. That You have not issued a pastoral notice addressing such disregard for His Majesty and His Mother at the Mass most people know, but instead focus on the one attended by a mere one thousand souls, is bewildering. Loathe as I am to say so, conscious of addressing Your Eminence, Your decision to implement Traditionis Custodes is cruel. It betrays the Gospel. I pray and hope it was a hastily considered one, and that it will be swiftly revoked, if not for my sake, but for those of my fellow Christians. 

Until then, I will be withholding my donations. This is done without malice. I still consider myself Your sheep until such time as I am not. In addition to revoking Your implementation of Traditionis Custodes, following Canon 212, I respectfully ask Your Eminence to: (a) allow the usus antiquor to be freely offered throughout the whole Archdiocese, every Sunday; (b) permit the other six sacraments to be freely offered in the usus antiquor; and (c) enforce the novus ordo Missae to be consistently offered with decorum, reverence, and precision, as mandated by the Second Vatican Council. Doing so will shower the Archdiocese with untold graces and restore Your reputation as a kind and compassionate bishop. 

In closing, Your Eminence, it pains me to write this letter in such a direct manner, but I have a duty to You as my father to approach you with my worries, my troubles, and my concerns about Your management of the Archdiocese. Again, it is my hope and prayer that Your decision to implement Traditionis Custodes was hastily considered, and that it will be swiftly retracted. May the Blessed Virgin, whom we dearly love, spread Her Mantle over You and shower You with the many graces You need as Cardinal. 

Kissing the Purple,

I remain,

In the Hearts of Jesus, Mary, and Joseph,

Your sheep,

"Archdiocese of Toronto" blames Rome and Traditionis Custodes - demands "filial devotion and Christian charity!"

In a bulletin released today in the weekly Archdiocesan Update, an "internal newsletter," chancery bureaucrats are running cover for Cardinal Frank Leo's cruel implementation of Traditionis Custodes, with demands that Catholics attending the Vetus Ordo of the Holy Mass fall in line with "patience, humility, filial devotion and Christian charity," as they "seek to preserve ecclesial unity" whilst ignoring all of that themselves. 

They continue that "These changes have become necessary because the archdiocese had not yet fully conformed to the canonical and disciplinary norms set out in the motu proprio Traditionis Custodes and subsequent documents." (Which does seem to throw Thomas Cardinal Collins under the bus). In so doing, they admit that the Archdiocese of Toronto has not been following the utterly repugnant "law" enacted based on lies and deception by Jorge Bergoglio and his frontman, Arthur Roche, pictured here entering a Roman Trattoria with Cardinal Leo in June.  No doubt, this is where the smackdown for the Archdiocese of Toronto and its multi-year-long disobedience of so-called "law" occurred and rather than protest this injustice, Cardinal Leo's "filial devotion" ranked higher than the sheep on the peripheries who have been thrown under a Roman bus without an espresso, let alone a biscotti.

Interesting that nothing appears on the web page of ArchToronto.org, and no letter of comfort to the hurt, betrayed and suffering faithful has been issued with the Cardinal's signature. No comment at all from Frank Leo, the Cardinal, not Frank Leo the real estate sales superstar. Unlike the Archbishop of Moncton in New Brunswick, who wrote kind words to the faithful after establishing the traditional liturgy with the help of the Institute of the Good Shepherd, there are no kind words of comfort to the souls at Holy Family, St. Vincent de Paul in Toronto or St. Lawrence the Martyr in Scarborough, or St. Patrick's in Schomberg. They don't receive the internal newsletter. 

Let me be perfectly clear about "preserving ecclesial unity."

First, this blogger is not breaking unity. The people in those four parishes have not and are not breaking unity. Unity does not mean the same. Unity means we are united in Christ with the Holy Church under the Pope. Popes can err, Francis did, many times. Traditionis Custodes is a cruel document based on lies, hatred for our faith and vengeance. It is the last desperate cry of generation that knows their time is short, "motus in fine velocior!" They must destroy the Old Rite because they know their work has been less than straw.

Secondly, they are hypocrites. They are not "preserving ecclesial unity." They are chasing people to the Society of St. Pius X (to whom I hold great respect). They are failing at "Christian charity" as they have not shown it to the smelly sheep.

It is far beyond time for Pope Leo XIV to act. 

Traditionis Custodes must be abolished!

St. Aloysius Gonzaga Parish of the FSSP in Thorold, Ontario - spectacular chapel renovation!

 

If I really loved Our Blessed Mother, if I were really "Marian" would I...

If I truly loved Our Blessed Mother and genuinely lived as “Marian” as I claim, what would that look like? Would I be generous and kind, a true friend and leader to those entrusted to me? If I were a priest or bishop, how would I treat those under my care? Would I meet them where they are, venture to the peripheries, live humbly among my brothers, and cherish the little flock’s spiritual welfare? Would I embrace even those who prefer the traditional worship of God, respecting their needs and recognizing unity in diversity, or would I harm and disregard them, ignoring their sincere desire to live according to conscience and raise their families in faith? Would I listen to and answer questions with respect, clarity, and charity, or rule harshly and abuse my authority? Would I be driven by ambition for higher positions, sacrificing the vulnerable to impress superiors, strutting like a peacock? The truth of these questions is laid bare before us.

The new Bishop's Palace in the Metropolitan Archdiocese of Lawrence Park

One of the first things that struck me when Thomas Cardinal Collins became Archbishop of Toronto in 2007 was his choice of residence. Gerald Emmett Cardinal Carter lived in a mansion in leafy Rosedale, a well-known "old-money" 19th-century neighbourhood in Toronto. Aloysius Cardinal Ambrozic opted for a condominium. Neither had chosen to live in the Bishop's Palace, the oldest building in Toronto still in continuous use for its original purpose. Now, it is not much of a "palace," but that is what it is called. It is a beautiful 19th-century Gothic mansion or "rectory" built alongside and attached to the 1848 Cathedral Basilica of St. Michael the Archangel. The more subdued third-storey is a later addition.

To his credit, not only did Collins decide immediately to live there, but he eventually undertook a dignified restoration of the Cathedral and the Bishop's Palace and Rectory. That rectory did not just house His Eminence but also the Cathedral Rector and Associates (I miss the term, curate), and priests who work in the Chancery or hospital chaplaincy. It was a literal priestly community. There were even some nights of the week when the dinner was communal with the Cardinal present. (No comment from me about the stories I've heard.)

Toronto Catholics may be interested in knowing that we have returned to the regal cardinalate of a Prince of the Church. 

Once a year, for the Christmas Carol concert before Midnight Mass, Emmett Carter would process in and then preside from the throne wearing the cappa magna. He thought his congregation should see him in full princely regalia, but Cardinal Collins saw it differently. In 2015, I was the Director of Music and one of the two main organizers of a “Mass in the Presence of a Greater Prelate” on the Vigil of Pentecost, honouring Toronto Monsignor Vincent Foy for 75 years of priesthood. Collins presided over the Mass in the usus antiquior, or Vetus Ordo, from the throne, assisted by four deacons, with all the traditional pomp, the debut of the new Metropolitan Cross, and plenty of “smells and bells.” The only thing we didn’t push on him was the cappa, knowing well by then the treatment a few years earlier of poor Bishop Slattery, even by other bishops at the National Shrine of the Immaculate Conception in Washington, D.C., for donning it at a pontifical mass.

Curiously, the new Metropolitan Archbishop of Toronto, Frank Leo (that's Frank Leo the Cardinal, not Frank Leo, local real estate magnate), has decided against residing in the place intended for him, opting instead for a grand and stylish mansion in Lawrence Park—at the former home no less, owned by the Chief Financial Officer of the Roman Catholic Episcopal Corporation for the Archdiocese of Toronto. Gosh, how much were they paying him? But good on him, eh? It is rumoured to have cost, with renovations, over $7,000,000, or maybe there was a discount from the employee, and not counting whatever lavish renovations followed by a certain amateur architect priest now forced to retire over it. One can’t help but imagine the new Prince of the Church, Frank Leo, sweeping through his opulent halls in a great cape perfectly befitting his majestic new abode. It would just not fit in with the prostitutes, crack-heads, sidewalk defecating homeless, noise, smells and gay-village aspects of Church Street. I mean, what of the "smell of the sheep" or going out to the "peripheries?" Where is the "accompaniment?" 

Naturally, Toronto Catholics wouldn’t dream of begrudging our spiritual leader the privilege of living among the well-heeled in places like Rosedale or Lawrence Park —past and present—like John Tory or world-famous architect Eric Arthur, Group of Seven artist A.J. Casson (I even have a signed print), astronaut Roberta Bondar, athletes like Gary Roberts, and more; enjoying the lap of luxury—at the expense of those in the pews—would we?

Oh, and inquiring minds wish to know: did Frank Leo handle the real estate transaction for Frank Leo?

Lawrence Park, Toronto - Wikipedia

Archdiocese of Toronto suspends Permanent Deacon program

 

Another look back at the betrayal at the Desolate City of the Archdiocese of Toronto and the lost Dialogue of Trust

Just over two years ago, I wrote this exposé, finally prompted to release known information by the putrid and sickening public clarity of an "alleged" sexual assault committed by Thomas Rosica, a now-suspended Basilian priest known to readers of this blog in particular for his slap-suit against this writer. I had had more than enough of this filth. I also decided to write it as a literal service to the new Archbishop of Toronto, Francis Leo. Clearly, he did not appreciate the gift.

I had read The Desolate City by Anne Roche Muggeridge in 1987. It was, along with the Ottawa Oratory in Formation at St. Brigid's, my Catholic rebirth and awakening. In that book, she referred to a scandalous memorandum issued by the then Rector of St. Augustine's Seminary, Brian Clough. After that, they removed him, sent him to the Catholic University of America for Canon Law, and returned him to Toronto to serve as Judicial Vicar until he retired a few years ago. That memorandum, called "A Dialogue of Trust," was lost. Well, it was lost until about five years ago, when I found it online in an archived issue of The Body Politic, a defunct sodomite newspaper in Toronto. I gradually transcribed it and sat on it and other information before finally exposing it.  

My reward was to be told that a Toronto priest was threatened with an end to the Latin Mass because of it. That is how these people act. Rather than respond, they threaten. It is not the first time that this writer was threatened by these churchmen. It has happened before, at least twice. It was serious and blatant, and it is not something I can write about here at this time.  

What this did was prove to me that everything I heard over the years was true and it needed to be exposed. You, the Catholics of Toronto, needed to know this history and to somehow hold these scandalous priests and bishops accountable. I was told by the threatened priest that you had no right to know and that I was creating scandal. I mourn the loss of that relationship. I can only recall the quote attributed to St. Gregory the Great: "It is better that scandal should arise than truth be suppressed." 

I invite you to click on the link below to this story, which will remain in the right column for easy access. It is a long read; it is not pleasant. 

Do not let them win. Hold fast to the Truth of Christ. Do not abandon the Church. Go to the Traditional Latin Mass; insist that the new mass be offered properly with the proper music and the proper disposition and following the rubrics. Show them you won't be abused anymore! 

Vox Cantoris: A look back at The Desolate City of the Archdiocese of Toronto and a lost "Dialogue of Trust"

Vox Cantoris: A look back at The Desolate City of the Archdiocese of Toronto and a lost "Dialogue of Trust"

Frank Leo, the "Metropolitan," not the real estate guy, lunches at Roman Trattoria with Arthur Roche

Well, well, well, what have we here? Check out the man trailing on the left, trailing behind Daddy Roche. Frank Leo, “Metropolitan” Archbishop of Toronto, on his way to enjoy lunch at a Roman trattoria with Art Roche. 

Is this where the plan to go after traditional Latin Mass-loving Catholics in Toronto was cooked up? 

Roche was a close and intimate friend of Doug Crosby, the retired Bishop of Hamilton. When Crosby arrived from Labrador, he brought along a couple of intriguing priests and appointed them as “co-pastors” in Hamilton. What was that all about? Crosby also served as co-consecrator and mentor to Frank Leo. Back in 1987, I was living in Ottawa and attended the “Oratory in formation” at St. Brigid’s, which was dismantled by modernists who aggressively targeted the good priests from St. Joseph’s parish. And the pastor at the time? Doug Crosby. So, what does it all add up to?

Let the reader discern. 

Toronto Catholics at St. Lawrence the Martyr Scarborough, St. Patrick's Schomberg and the Oratory parishes!

Dear Friends,

Some of you know me personally, while most do not. This blog has now reached over 15 million readers, with its influence reaching around the world and even read regularly in the chancery in Toronto. It played a big role in exposing a priest guilty of plagiarism and worse, as well as calling out those who have, for decades, abused children and the faithful of Toronto in many ways. “No Mass for You” (see left column) still hits a nerve! 

Want more? 

My exposé on the horrific abuse at St. Augustine’s Seminary in the 1970s and 1980s, along with its dark secrets (see left for The Desolate City and a Lost Dialogue of Trust), brought threats against both you and me. I was told firsthand by a priest who was warned that the Latin Mass would be persecuted because of me and that post. That was nearly two years ago, and here we are. I don’t buy it. They hate us; they hate the old Mass of our ancestors. They flaunt their “Mariology” and Marian devotion, organize Corpus Christi processions—but do they even believe? I say no, because if they did, they wouldn’t act the way they do or commit such cruelty. Further, they would not hate the old Mass; they would recognize its worth, its beauty, its history and its Truth.

They want a fight? They’ve got one!

Are you ready?

They declared war on you and your children? Are you going to take it?  

Do you think that this is where they will stop? If only our parents and grandparents had this little tool. I do. You do. Use it.

Send an email to me at david.domet@outlook.com

Tell me what this persecution by our Metropolitan Archbishop, Francis Cardinal Leo, over your attendance at the traditional Latin Mass means to you—your anger, your hurt, your disappointment, your fears, your tears, your hopes.

I will publish them here, including your name unless you request otherwise.

I’ll make sure Frank Leo (the cardinal, not the real estate magnate) sees them right here.

Oh, and speaking of real estate.

Stay tuned for tomorrow.

Archdiocese of Toronto implements Traditionis Custodes!

Since late spring, we have known that the Archdiocese of Toronto must implement Traditionis Custodes. Under the instruction of Metropolitan Archbishop Francis Cardinal Leo, the Auxiliary bishops met with Father Russell Asch, chaplain for the traditional liturgy in Scarborough (St. Lawrence the Martyr), Schomberg (St. Patrick’s), and the Toronto Oratory (Holy Family and St. Vincent de Paul), to discuss and set future implementation dates. 

Father Asch was required to act in June. The Toronto Oratory continued discussions and is now implementing the instruction effective Sunday, September 20, 2026. 

Our good friend, Toronto Catholic Witness, was at Mass yesterday at St. Vincent de Paul and filed the following report. 

TORONTO CATHOLIC WITNESS: Rome is suppressing the Latin Mass and Traditional Sacraments in the Archdiocese of Toronto

Let us first take a look at some history. 

The Masses at Schomberg and Scarborough have existed for over 40 years under the late Father Liam Gavigan. He had a personal "celebret" and was authorized by the late Cardinal Aloysius Ambrozic under the indult permitted according to Ecclesia Dei Afflicta of John Paul II. In the early 1990's, the Oratorians were given charge of a second parish, neighbouring  Holy Family, St. Vincent de Paul. A few years later, the Society of St. Pius X purchased a small Baptist church in the next parish from St. Vincent de Paul and opened a Mass Centre. Cardinal Ambrozic approached the Oratorians, who already offered the Novus Ordo sung in Latin at Holy Family, to begin a traditional liturgy at St. Vincent de Paul on Sundays and Holy Days of Obligation to draw people away from going to the SSPX. Cardinal Thomas Collins continued and encouraged the growth. 

The late Very Reverend Jonathan Robinson, Cong. Orat., offering Solemn Mass at Holy Family Church

Effective next Sunday, September 20, one Mass per month scheduled in the usus antiquior must be said according to the Novus Ordo. At St. Vincent, the old high altar will be used, as it is now, and at Holy Family it must face the people. The Mass at St. Vincent will be simply read, along with the earlier one. At Holy Family, it will be sung in Latin, facing the people, with music according to the new rite, as they did there from arriving in Toronto until changing it to the traditional and evolving to Solemn weekly. 

No other sacraments are permitted according to the traditional usage. 

All four parishes have sufficient English-language Masses, and at St. Lawrence the Martyr, Italian Masses according to the new rite. There is no demand to remove these from Latin Mass-goers, and no demand from others to remove the Latin Mass. People are free to choose. 

A rough calculation of numbers is revealing. At these four Masses and the Society of St. Pius X masses at two locations, there are not more than 1,200 people attending, and that is a generous estimate; it may be less than 1,000. 

Let the reader discern. 

 

More Papal "blah, blah, blah..." on the matter of Sacred Music and Sacrosanctam Concilium. But what about Tra le sollecitudini and the Chirograph on Sacred Music?

It seems that at the weekly papal audience, Pope Leo XIV has made some comments about sacred music.

General Audience of 19 August 2026 - Catechesis. The Documents of the Second Vatican Council. III. Constitution Sacrosanctum Concilium. 7. Sacred Music

How marvellous. 

Does anyone remember this?

Chirograph for the Centenary of the Motu Proprio Tra le Sollecitudini On Sacred Music (December 3, 2003)

Why do our Bishops of Rome, from St. Pius X to Pope Leo XIV, continue on this track and remain ignored by the overwhelming majority of liturgically ignorant bishops and priests throughout the Latin Rite?

In the case of the "Metropolitan" Archdiocese of Toronto and the glorious St. Michael's Cathedral, has anyone noticed the banal dumbing down of the liturgy and music program?

Deacon John Griglio asks for prayers.

Friends,

If you follow this blog's blog-links on the left column, you may have seen this:

The site has been very helpful to me, and I am sure, to many of you. It is owned by Deacon John Griglio, a retired Deacon of the Diocese of Brooklyn. Deacon Griglio has a few other blogs and WordPress pages as well.

He posted this yesterday.

Dear Friends, yesterday we began hospice at home because of my cancer, as my body seems to be shutting down. I am quite weak and will try to post to you when I can. I have plenty of care, with nurses and caregivers attending to my medical and living needs. Our new pastor, Fr. Wright, visited me, and I received the Anointing of the Sick and Holy Communion. I also have my wonderful family who will nourish me. I look forward to being in heaven soon, in the Sacred Hearts of Jesus and Mary, with all the Angels and Saints, singing praises to the Most Blessed Trinity for all eternity! I just ask for your prayers as I struggle with this time of my life. God bless us all ✝️   

Deacon John Giglio

God bless you, Reverend Deacon. Thank you for your service to our Lord Jesus Christ, His Church and His people, including this sinner.

The Metropolitan Archbishop of Moncton on the Traditional Latin Mass

When? When, my fellow Canadian Catholics, have you ever read anything like this from a bishop? May God grant his grace and long life to Metropolitan Archbishop of Moncton, His Excellency, the Most Reverend Guy Derochers, C.Ss.R.   

Moncton TLMS

His Excellency the Most Reverend Guy Desrochers, C.Ss.R. 

Sunday, July 19, 2026 

Dear Faithful, 

As Bishop of the Catholic Church in the Archdiocese of Moncton, I consider all Catholics, whether practicing or not, following either the older Latin rite of Mass or the reformed rite since Vatican II, to be part of the one flock that Jesus entrusts to me and to my delegates, his chosen priests and deacons, to govern, sanctify, and teach our brothers and sisters, so that all may one day enter the kingdom of God and be fully part of his one and glorious family in heaven. 

I give my apostolic blessing to Fr. Donoso and pray that, in his ministry, he will be a living witness to the love and mercy of God for you. I pray that he will always be a beacon of divine light and spiritual comfort to all of you and to all who will be entrusted to his pastoral care. May all of us, dear people of God, always remain united as a family, through the Sacred Heart of Jesus and the Immaculate Heart of Mary, living in divine charity and respect for one another at all times. As Jesus said: « Just as I have loved you, you also should love one another. By this everyone will know that you are my disciples, if you have love for one another. » — John 13:34–35 

Finally, I ask our beloved God to bless each of you, and I assure you of my prayers and fraternal support. 

Welcome to our Diocese, Fr. Donoso! May you bear many spiritual fruits in your priestly ministry. 

Metropolitan Archbishop of Moncton,

Most Reverend Guy Desrochers, C.Ss.R.

Moncton TLMS

Feast of the Transfiguration of the LORD - O Nata Lux by Thomas Tallis

Effeminate Cardinal Cochroach and his gaslighting

 

More Extraordinary Gaslighting: Cardinal Roche on the Traditional Latin Mass Yet Again

EXCOMMUNICATION IT IS FOR THE SSPX!

A pox on all of them.

This was not necessary.

The Society of St. Pius X waited too long to ask and did so with pride and arrogance. Those close to the Pope and he himself have failed in their duties for all to see. They have contributed to tearing the seamless garment of unity through their own arrogance and lack of charity and true love for the faithful. Shame on all of them. 

Father Gerald E. Murray SSPX: Schism and Excommunication - The Catholic Thing

Father John Zuhlsdorf SSPX Superior Fr. Pagliarani’s homily for the 1 July 2026 consecration of bishops | Fr. Z's Blog

Decreto del Dicastero per la Dottrina della Fede (2 luglio 2026)

Despite warnings given to the Superior General of the Priestly Fraternity of St. Pius X, Bishop Alfonso de Galarreta, having performed an act of schismatic nature by episcopal consecration of four priests without a pontifical mandate and against the will of the Supreme Pontiff, has ipso facto incurred the penalties provided by can. 1387 and can. 1364 § 1 CIC 2021. 

I therefore declare for all legal purposes that both the aforementioned Bishop Alfonso de Galarreta and Pascal Schreiber, Michael Goldade, Michel Poinsinet de Sivry, and Marc Hanappier have ipso facto incurred the latae sententiae excommunication reserved to the Apostolic See. 

I also declare that Bishop Bernard Fellay, having directly participated in the liturgical celebration as a co-consecrator, thus publicly adhering to the schismatic act, has incurred the latae sententiae excommunication provided by can. 1364 § 1 CIC 2021. 

Priests and lay faithful are warned not to join the schism of the Priestly Fraternity of St. Pius X, because they would automatically incur the penalty of excommunication. 

From the Dicastery Palace, July 2, 2026

And the "Explanatory note." My emphasis...

 

DICASTERY FOR THE DOCTRINE OF THE FAITH

Prot. N. 99/2009 

EXPLANATORY NOTE 

From the time of Pope Paul VI up to the most recent conversations held at this Dicastery, the many attempts to bring the adherents of the movement initiated by Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre back to full communion with the Catholic Church have proven fruitless. This situation has been further aggravated by the recent episcopal consecrations celebrated without a pontifical mandate, against the will of the Holy Father, in open violation of canon law. 

Accordingly, this Dicastery, in the faithful exercise of the functions entrusted to it, considers it necessary to note that this act has constituted the offense of schism, with the resulting canonical consequences for the sacred ministers and lay faithful involved. Indeed, as was already declared in 1988, "such disobedience — which carries with it a practical rejection of the Roman Primacy — constitutes a schismatic act" (cf. John Paul II, Apost. Letter Ecclesia Dei, 3). 

In this regard, henceforth: 

1. The sacred ministers belonging to the Society of Saint Pius X are in schism and must therefore be considered schismatics (cf. Ecclesia Dei, 5c; Pontifical Council for Legislative Texts, Explanatory Note on the excommunication for schism incurred by adherents of the movement of Bishop Marcel Lefebvre, 24.08.1996, 5–6), and are subject to the excommunication provided for by law (can. 1364 § 1 CIC). 

2. With regard to the lay faithful, those who formally adhere to the Society of Saint Pius X under the conditions established in the Explanatory Note of the Pontifical Council for Legislative Texts of 1996 (cf. ibid., 7) — still in force, and hereby adopted by this Dicastery — are to be considered schismatics and excommunicated. 

3. The holy People of God is hereby informed that the sacred ministers of the Society of Saint Pius X administer the sacraments illicitly, and that the sacrament of penance administered by them and the marriages they assist at are invalid. 

The Church, as a devoted mother, will receive with sincere affection and eager care all those who desire to return to full communion. The Apostolic Nuncios will have at their disposal the procedures that Ordinaries may employ in the various cases. 

Finally, all the faithful are exhorted to remain firm in communion with the Roman Pontiff, with the bishops in communion with him, and with the whole Church (cf. Lumen Gentium, 22; can. 751 CIC), and to refrain from participating in the celebrations and activities promoted by the aforementioned Society of Saint Pius X. 

From the Palace of the Dicastery, July 2, 2026 

Víctor M. Card. Fernández

Prefect 

Archbishop Armando Matteo

Secretary for the Doctrinal Section 

John J. Kennedy

Titular Archbishop of Ossero, Secretary for the Disciplinary Section