From Diane Montagna.
(4) Pope’s ‘Traditionis Custodes’ Remarks Prompt Plea to Restore Liturgical Peace
Most Holy Father,
I was deeply moved by the images of your visit to your former diocese of Chiclayo during your recent Apostolic Visit to Peru. It is clear that you loved your diocese and your clergy and people very much and that you were—and are—beloved by them still. Deo gratias!
The edification that this gives seems to reflect your pontificate to date. You seem to be a moderate man who is kind and who is seeking all that is good for the Church. You promote Christ and His teaching, often in challenging circumstances. You speak often of the need for reconciliation and unity in the Church and of promoting that communion of faith and life which is of her essence.
Whilst I struggle to understand how some of your actions in respect of other religious leaders are helpful, I know from various people who have met with you personally that you seek to understand the issues that they raise and that you assure them that their concerns will be addressed. It certainly cannot be easy being the Pope!
It was, therefore, with some astonishment and, indeed, no small amount of sorrow, that your remarks during your in-flight press conference returning from Peru concerning the older liturgical rites (the usus antiquior) appeared this morning.
The astonishment was caused by your statement that “for the unity of the Church, the vast majority of Catholics around the world, we celebrate the rite of Vatican II.” The sorrow was due to the pastoral implications that these remarks will have.
Holiness, unity is not uniformity, as your comments about the different practices in the countries you visited in your Apostolic Visit reflect. Strict liturgical uniformity is foreign to the history of the Roman rite, as Pope Benedict XVI, an efficacious artisan of liturgical peace and of ecclesial communion, knew only too well. Unity in the one Catholic faith and ecclesial communion does not exclude legitimate ritual diversity as the Eastern Churches, the Ambrosian rite and the Ordinariate Use demonstrate clearly today.
So too, the “decision” of your predecessor that you state will be kept for now was predicated on falsehoods (the Survey of the world’s bishops by the then CDF simply did not say what Traditionis Custodes claims it did) and was, it seems, little more than the political manoeuvring of various prelates overly concerned about the success and real fruit being generated by the generous measures enacted by Pope Benedict XVI.
Most of the world’s bishops then, did not (and probably now, do not) have a problem with a legitimate liturgical diversity that bears good fruit, particularly amongst the young. So too, when they used their pastoral judgement and legitimate canonical prerogatives to dispense their dioceses from the restrictions Traditionis Custodes imposed, their rights were removed by a hastily-obtained rescript restricting them even further.
Holiness, in its quest for rigid uniformity Traditionis Custodes has sown division and disunity. When their parsimonious bishops have prohibited the celebration of the Mass and the Sacraments in the usus antiquior, faithful Catholics have sought refuge in the Society of St Pius X, in the Orthodox Churches or elsewhere. These individuals and their communities deserve to be listened to and heard. Their suffering is real. Bridges need to be built for them so that unity and communion is maintained.
Further division and disunity will flow if Traditionis Custodes is maintained. Pope Benedict took the matter out of the hands of diocesan bishops for a reason—or perhaps two: their unrealistic attachment to an ideology that everything following the Second Vatican Council was perfect and is irreformable, and their ultimate ultramontanism. The former he sought to correct. The latter, in a way, he used for the pastoral good of the Church by underlining his clear-sighted theology and his paternal generosity with his papal authority.
Your Holiness, please use your authority to remove the barrier to unity and communion that Traditionis Custodes and its interpretive documents and its zealous acolytes in fact are. Dispensations from these measures have proved few and far between and depend on too many subjective factors to bear real or consistent fruit.
Please return the Church to that generous and fruitful liturgical peace and unity fostered by the gentle scholar pope, Benedict XVI, through his permitting the free celebration all the older liturgical rites—the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass, the Sacraments and other rites—spiritual riches that “earlier generations held as sacred [and that remain] sacred and great for us too, and [and that] cannot be all of a sudden entirely forbidden or even considered harmful.” Please “preserve [these] riches which have developed in the Church’s faith and prayer, and…give them their proper place.”
Your Holiness, from the first moments of your ministry we have prayed for you earnestly and fervently, and we shall continue so to do. Please hear this plea as a father. Please hear it as a bishop. Please hear it as the Pope. Give us a share in that joy and pride in you which warms the hearts of the people of Chiclayo still, and which we have been privileged to witness in recent days.
To that end, Your Holiness, know that you can always count on our support and on our prayers for your ministry.
Dom Alcuin Reid
Prior, Monastère Saint-Benoît, Brignoles, France

No comments:
Post a Comment