"RORATE" Traditional Latin Mass in the Archdiocese of Toronto

Thursday, 24 November 2011

Celebrate in Song: Two critiques of the new CCCB booklet

Here is my article from the December 2011 edition of Catholic Insight. Permission has been granted for a reprint at http://www.canticanova.com/.

You can read it all, here:

Celebrate in Song: Two critiques of the new CCCB booklet
By Raymond Lévesque and David Domet
Issue: December 2011
Attending one of the workshops in Toronto at Annunciation parish on the music for the new Missal I was amused to find that one of the presenters, a "professional liturgist" in front of over 400 people would say; "they (ICEL) have even set the Nicene Creed to music; why anyone would want to sing the Creed is beyond me."

Indeed.

When questioned as to the Propers, she responded, "What are they?"

This from one of Canada's professional liturgists does not speak well for the rest of Celebrate in Song.

The three settings composed by Canadian composers are no closer to the ideal of what the Church expects and calls Sacred Music than that which is mostly now tolerated.


3 comments:

LUZ DE MARIA PARA AS NAÇÕES said...

Congratulations!
I invite you to put this blog the image of the Lady of All Peoples with the prayer taught by her for a fresh outpouring of the Holy Spirit worldwide. Welcome to: www.virgemdeguadalupe.blogspot.com

Anonymous said...

Propers  -  Some fatherly advice.

Mike

Anonymous said...

Thw Chant Cafe removed the post with this video